Beneath the steadying fear of Darkest Dungeon
So close to shattering, but still they press onward.
My Hellion is about to die.
This isn’t the dramatic climax to her story. This is not the point when I realize that all of her character development was leading to this moment, that her braggadocio was a front for a long-standing inner weakness. There will be no scene in which she declares that even a coward can be brave, when she needs to be, ramming her glaive into the throat of some howling beast before it slices her crippled body to ribbons. No, in a turn or two she will just die, unless my other team members can save her in time, because that’s the nature of Darkest Dungeon.
And I’m seventeen again, standing outside of my girlfriend’s dorm, my mother standing there and explaining to me in completely alien calm that my father is dead, that the last time I had spoken to him was the last time I would say a word to him, that I had no control over that, either. Which is why Darkest Dungeon can at once be brilliant and horrid at equal turns, the sort of game that I would recommend to almost anyone but with several rather strict caveats despite how much I enjoy it.
Telling Stories: Stopping points
If there has been only one theme to the many things that I have written about roleplaying over the years – and there have, in fact, been many themes – I would hope that one of the ones that gets hit on the regular is the idea that no one should make you feel pressured to continue a scene when you aren’t having fun. You should always have the freedom to say that you need to stop and take a break, or that a scene is making you uncomfortable, or the like.
You should also have the freedom to say that you need to take a nap or go have dinner with your family or just that if you stay at the computer any longer you’re going to develop some kind of infection.
Roleplaying is like any other activity insofar as it’s not fun when it becomes a slog. A lot of people prefer to have roleplaying as an open-ended thing, an act I wholeheartedly endorse and agree with. But it’s important despite that to have stopping points and give players the freedom to step away, and knowing that there are hard stopping points can ultimately make for better roleplaying.
Challenge Accepted: Forever running
There is no permanent failure, just different steps on the road to success, most of which involve persistence.
When you play Peggle, there is a finite puzzle to solve in each level. No additional pegs will crop up to assail your dwindling supply of balls, you will not rush ahead to the next level with the same number of balls you began play with, there are no carryover elements from one stage to the next. You clear the puzzle as it’s presented to you and that’s enough.
When you play Lumines, this isn’t the case. The game starts, and it keeps going until you screw up. That’s the long and short of it. The challenge will just continue for as long as you play. And while both games are fundamentally puzzle games, one of them is a game wherein each level should be played to completion, while the other is an ongoing process. And there are some interesting differences between a challenge that just runs forever and one that exists in a contained space.
Demo Driver 8: Dollar Dash
If anyone ever asks me to explain EVE Online again, I’m just going to lock them in a room where they have nothing to play other than this game. That should serve as an object lesson.
The problem with any sort of endless game is that you have to provide a reason why people are going to keep playing. You need to offer something, well, unique.
It’d be unfair to say that Dollar Dash is a bad game. As games go, it’s pretty well functional. I might argue that it’s on the lower side of functional, but that’s not the point and it doesn’t really help or hurt the game on the balance. The problem it has isn’t about whether or not it works.
No, the problem is that it’s a game with the barest form of a game beyond the expectation of having multiple players beating the snot out of one another on a regular basis. Its single-player offering is perfunctory, there to train you and help you unlock things for the online experience, and that online experience is reliant on people deciding that they’d rather play this game as opposed to the countless entries doing the same thing, only better. It’s surplus to requirements, and it offers little to compel the player to care.
Recent Work
- Square-Enix states that Outriders is off to a good start thanks in part to Xbox Game Pass 06/22/2021
- ArcheAge adds June update, offers players free stuff for the summer 06/22/2021
- Final Fantasy XIV ups tomestone limits and timeworn artifact rewards with patch 5.57 06/22/2021
- Elyon recaps its first closed beta and plans its second for mid-August 06/21/2021
- Wisdom of Nym: Things to do in Final Fantasy XIV while you’re waiting for Endwalker 06/21/2021
Chocobo Dash
- Chocobo Dash, A FFXIV Podcast: 008 06/25/2014
- Chocobo Dash, A FFXIV Podcast: 007 06/25/2014
